Introduction
In a country as vast and diverse as India, where inequality, poverty, and bureaucratic inefficiency often hinder justice, Public Interest Litigation (PIL) has become one of the most powerful tools for ordinary people to gain an advantage. PIL was introduced by the Indian judiciary in the late 20th century, which granted individuals, social groups or organizations the ability to take legal action against issues that are related to the public good rather than just personal grievances.
Consider the possibility of challenging government inaction on pollution in your city, advocating for improved conditions among detainees, highlighting exploitative labour practices and seeking reprieve for illegally held under-trial prisoners, all without being directly affected. A PIL possesses such immense power. A citizen no longer remains a passive observer, but instead becomes involved in governance and social justice.
The most notable aspect of PILs is their accessibility. Whether you're a lawyer, victim or just hurting someone else. To do so, one must have a strong sense of public interest, provide credible evidence and demonstrate an unwavering commitment to accountability. In cases where the petitioner lacked formal legal resources, the Supreme Court of India has accepted handwritten letters as PILs.
Great power comes with great responsibility. There has been a rise in the misuse of PILs, with some petitions being filed for political reasons, personal gain or harassment. Today, the courts are scrutinizing PILs more closely to eliminate any false allegations.
Learn all about the steps involved in filing a PIL in India by reading this brief summary:
* Can you explain what a PIL is and when it can be filed
* Who has the right to file and which courts have jurisdiction over it?
* Practical tips on writing, submitting information and following through
* The impact of landmark decisions on Indian legislation and administration
It provides a comprehensive guide for individuals of all types, including students and activists alike as well as journalists/justice practitioners (lawyer), who want to use PILs to make meaningful changes in society.
This blog post, will explain what a PIL is, how to file one and walk you through landmark judgements those demonstrate its value.
In Legal Terms, What is a PIL?
To defend public interest in a court of law, one must file ILs for the purpose of protecting it. The filing of a PIL differs from typical legal cases in that it can be filed by any party, not just those involved.
In High Courts and the Supreme Court of India, it is common to file PILs under various circumstances:
* Article 226 of the Constitution (High Courts).
* Article 32 of the Constitution (Supreme Court).
* These regulations maintain the availability of the judiciary for every citizen, particularly those who are poor, illiterate or unemployed.
How do you determine when it is appropriate to submit a PIL?
In the event that:
* The violation of fundamental human rights is happening among the underprivileged and excluded.
* A violation of constitutional or legal duties by a public authority.
* It has an impact on the general public, be it environmental degradation, corruption or public health concerns.
Who Can File a PIL?
* A PIL can be filed by any Indian citizen or organization.
* The petitioner doesn't have to be directly involved in the matter.
* PILs can be submitted by courts as a form of correspondence if the issue is significant and of public interest.
* NGOs and social activists.
* Lawyers and journalists.
* The court itself (suo moto).
Procedure to File a PIL
Here's a step-by-step guide:
1. Identify the Issue
Choose something that affects everyone or a community.... For example:
* Violation of fundamental rights.
* Environmental pollution in a river.
* Inhumane treatment of prisoners.
* Child exploitation in a specific locality.
* Corruption and misappropriation of public funds.
2. Do Your Research
Acquire documentation, government records and photos along with media reports, affidavits and other evidence of your case.
3. Draft the Petition
The PIL should include:
* Detailed facts of the issue
* Violation of legal/constitutional rights
* Evidence supporting the claim
* Requesting prayer or relief (your wish for court)
The petition should be:
* The document is presented as an affidavit and has been authenticated with proper signatures.
* Presented in either the High Court or Supreme Court, depending on the area of law to address.
4. Filing the PIL
* To file in the Supreme Court, one must comply with Article 32.
* File under Article 226 if present in the High Court.
You can either:
* File it yourself if you're familiar with the court process
* Find an attorney with expertise in constitutional or civil rights law
5. Court's Preliminary Scrutiny
The court will decide whether the PIL is fictitious or genuine. Why? If the case is deemed to be in the public interest, it will proceed. A warning or penalty may be given to dismiss the matter if it is not addressed.
6. Notice to Respondents
The government authorities, agencies, or private parties are notified by the court for their response if they acknowledge it.
7. Court Hearings and Verdict
The court can appoint committees, seek expert opinions, or issue instructions to settle the case. The ultimate verdict could lead to significant policy alterations or clear concessions.
8. Filing Fees for a PIL
The goal is to make PILs affordable:
* Typically, the Supreme Court fee is nominal.
* While variations exist, High Courts generally adhere to a nominal approach.
Famous/Landmark PIL Cases in India
1. MC Mehta v. Union of India's [Ganga Pollution Case]
* Environmental lawyer MC Mehta has filed.
* Issue: Industrial pollution in the Ganga River.
* The Supreme Court's decision to implement closure or treatment mechanisms for polluting industries had a significant impact on the development of environmental law in India.
2. Vishaka & others v. State of Rajasthan (1997)
* Bhanwari Devi's gang rape has left women' groups feeling the absence of protection.
* Problem: The absence of regulations against sexual harassment in the workplace.
* The Vishaka Guidelines were established by the Supreme Court as a foundation for passing the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace Act, 2013.
3. Sheela Barse & others v. Union of India [1986]
* Filed By: Journalist Sheela Barse
* Issue: Mistreatment of children in prisons. Kindness and respect.
* The Supreme Court issued guidelines for safeguarding children who are in custody.
4. Hussainara Khatoon v. State of Bihar (1979)
* Filed By: Advocate Kapila Hingorani
* Problem: Overcrowded incarceration cases, under review for years and without trial.
* Landmark verdict that resulted in the release of over 40,000 individuals from trials and highlighted the importance of speedy trial as a fundamental right.
5. NALSA v. Union of India (2014)
* The government was directed to treat transgender individuals as a third gender in accordance with the rights of citizens. This case is significant.
Information on the appropriate time to file a PIL: Important Things
Do:
* Establish that the matter is truly of public interest.
* Gather credible and factual evidence.
* Provide clear and concise instructions for prayer to the court.
* Follow the guidelines of court procedural standards.
Don't:
* Employ PILs to demonstrate their personal or political motives.
* Produce PILs to market or harass individuals.
* Give misleading or fabricated evidence.
Conclusion
Public Interest Litigations have been one of the most effective instruments for social transformation and judicial activism in India. PILs have resulted in numerous beneficial changes, including those related to environmental protection, human rights, women's safety, and corruption. Moreover,
To make a genuine difference, PIL is necessary if you believe that the public is being unfairly treated. What are your options? Justice can be served for thousands with the right intent and evidence.
Got a Question or Experience to Share?
Have you ever considered filing a PIL or know someone who did? Share your story in the comments or contact us.
The inspiration or idea for writing this blog originated from this source
